Nov 8, 2009 -- 2:29PM, Tjspea01 wrote:

Nov 8, 2009 -- 2:25PM, The Great Randy Orton wrote:

Nov 8, 2009 -- 2:24PM, Tjspea01 wrote:

Nov 8, 2009 -- 2:20PM, The Great Randy Orton wrote:

Nov 8, 2009 -- 1:59PM, Tjspea01 wrote:

Randy Orton or Cm Punk and why......

My vote goes to Cm Punk, this is his breakout year lets look at his accomplishments shall we......

Cm Punk:
-1st person to win the MITB ladder match 2 times 2 years in a row
-Won the 1st ever Samoan Strap match
-After the strap match he became World Heavyweight champion for a 2nd time
-Became an interesting heel
-Carried Smackdown as the top heel while Edge is gone (believe it or not he did make Smackdown interesting for awhile)
-Beat a TLC pioneer in a TLC match to win his 3rd world championship
-The following week after he won the title he retired Jeff Hardy
-main evented 3 PPV's in a row
-Made Taker "tap"

I don't think Orton has done anything better than that this year except punt the Mcmahons....dats about it.

Who do you think should win the Superstar Of The Year Award out of these 2.........

here is Randy's accomplishments
Royal Rumble
Taking the McMahons
Won 3 World Titles
Hell in a Cell
Triple Threat
3 Stages of Hell
Fatal Four Way
6 Man Tag Team Match
No Holds Barred
Carried Raw

Overall = Randy Orton

Dude ur stating the matches Randy has been in, that's not really an accomplishment considering that he lost a couple of them like the 6 man tag, and the No holds barred, besides, Punk is more interesting than Orton has been this year, I think it goes to Punk.

ur blind, Randy won the No Holds Barred and the 6 Man Tag Team Match at BL

My bad I was thinking about the falls count anywhere match and the match he had on Smackdown with Legacy and Cm Punk against Taker, Cena and DX, my fault ppl......

lol